Deciding to remove a tooth is never the first choice for comprehensive dental care, but sometimes extraction is the most responsible step to protect a patient’s long-term oral health. Our team approaches every recommendation with a focus on preservation and function; extractions are offered only when conservative restorations or other treatments cannot reliably restore comfort, form, or chewing ability. By explaining the reasons clearly and walking patients through alternatives, we help people feel informed and prepared.
Before recommending removal, the dentist will evaluate the tooth in the context of your bite, adjacent teeth, gum and bone health, and overall medical history. This evaluation includes a careful clinical exam and targeted imaging to reveal root shape, bone levels, and any hidden complications. The goal is to make a treatment decision that minimizes future problems while supporting overall oral stability.
When an extraction is advised, the clinical team prioritizes safety, predictable healing, and clear communication. Discussion typically covers short-term steps for the procedure itself as well as longer-term planning, such as options for replacing the missing tooth when appropriate. These follow-up restoration options are discussed so patients can make a plan that fits their oral health goals.
Primary (baby) teeth that won’t give way
Sometimes a primary tooth remains firmly in place after the permanent tooth is ready to erupt. This can happen when the roots of the baby tooth do not resorb normally or the tooth becomes fused to the jawbone. Left in place, an over-retained baby tooth may interfere with the proper alignment and eruption of permanent teeth, so timely removal can help guide normal development.
Permanents with extensive decay beyond repair
Dental decay starts on the outer enamel and can progress down into deeper layers if not treated. Once a tooth loses structural integrity or when the nerve and surrounding bone are compromised, restorative options like fillings or crowns may no longer be viable. In these situations, extraction prevents the spread of infection and preserves the health of neighboring teeth and tissues.
Teeth fractured or damaged past the point of restoration
Cracks and severe fractures vary widely in severity. When the break extends below the gumline or involves the root in a way that prevents a predictable repair, extracting the tooth may be the most reliable way to relieve pain and avoid ongoing complications. The choice to extract follows a thorough assessment of whether any restorative path would be durable and functional.
Advanced periodontal disease that undermines support
Periodontal disease targets the tissues that hold teeth in place—gums and underlying bone. When bone loss and pocketing become severe, a tooth can become loose and symptomatic. In cases where periodontal therapy cannot restore sufficient support, removal may be necessary to stop disease progression and protect overall oral health.
Impacted or problematic wisdom teeth
Third molars frequently lack space to erupt properly, which can lead to impaction, crowding, or recurrent infections. When wisdom teeth threaten adjacent teeth or cause ongoing symptoms, extraction is commonly recommended—especially when monitoring indicates future problems are likely. Early removal in appropriate cases can prevent more complex issues later on.
Extractions as part of orthodontic treatment
Some smiles require selective tooth removal to correct crowding and create room for an optimal bite and esthetic alignment. When orthodontic goals are best served by strategic extractions, the dental team coordinates closely with the orthodontist to plan which teeth are removed and how the space will be managed during treatment.
Preparation begins with a thorough medical and dental history review and a targeted exam. Because certain medical conditions and medications affect surgical risk and healing, it’s essential for clinicians to know about your overall health and any prescriptions you take. If additional precautions are needed, the dentist will explain them and arrange appropriate medical collaboration before proceeding.
We use digital radiography and other imaging as needed to map root positions, bone anatomy, and proximity to vital structures. These images guide whether the extraction can be performed simply in the dentist’s chair or whether surgical referral is the safer option. Clear imaging helps minimize surprises and contributes to a predictable outcome.
On the day of the procedure you’ll receive local anesthesia to numb the area; sedation options can be discussed in advance if anxiety or the complexity of the case warrants them. During a routine (simple) extraction, the tooth is loosened and removed using elevators and forceps. For teeth that are broken, impacted, or otherwise inaccessible, a surgical approach—often performed by an oral surgeon—may require a small incision and gentle removal of some overlying bone to access the tooth safely.
Simple extraction: This approach is used when a tooth is fully visible and the roots are straightforward. After the area is numbed, the clinician loosens the tooth and removes it with forceps. The technique is efficient, and most patients experience minimal discomfort when provided with appropriate pain control and post-operative instructions.
Surgical extraction: Teeth that are impacted, fractured at the gumline, or fused to bone often require a surgical method. The procedure may involve a small incision in the gum and precise removal of bone around the root to allow safe extraction. Surgical extractions may produce slightly more post-operative swelling and require sutures, but they are performed to protect adjacent structures and ensure complete removal when a simple approach is not possible.
Most people find the first 24–72 hours after an extraction to be the most uncomfortable, with gradual improvement thereafter. Pain and swelling are normal responses to tissue healing and can usually be managed with prescribed or over-the-counter medications as recommended. It’s helpful to plan a brief period of rest and to follow specific care directions that support clot formation and tissue repair.
Keeping the extraction site undisturbed is a key element of recovery. Avoiding vigorous rinsing, spitting, smoking, or using a straw reduces the risk of dislodging the clot that forms in the socket. Gentle oral hygiene away from the site and short-term dietary adjustments—favoring soft, cool foods—make the recovery period more comfortable while minimizing irritation to the tissue.
If sutures are placed, the team will tell you whether they are dissolving or will need removal at a follow-up appointment. Watching for warning signs like persistent heavy bleeding, worsening pain after a few days, or fever helps ensure prompt attention if a complication develops. Routine follow-up allows the clinician to confirm proper healing and plan any necessary restorative steps.
Control bleeding with gentle pressure
Bite gently on the provided gauze until bleeding subsides. If bleeding continues heavily after repeated changes of gauze, contact the practice for guidance. Light oozing for up to a day is common, but heavy or prolonged bleeding should be evaluated.
Be careful while numb
Avoid chewing or touching the area until sensation returns to reduce the risk of accidental injury to lips, cheeks, or tongue while the local anesthetic is active.
Follow medication instructions
If antibiotics or pain medications are prescribed, take them exactly as directed to support healing and control infection and discomfort. Over-the-counter pain relievers can be effective for many patients when used as recommended.
Protect the clot
Avoid rinsing forcefully, using straws, or any activity that creates suction in the mouth during the initial days. Allow the blood clot to secure itself in the socket to promote uncomplicated healing.
Manage swelling
Applying a cold pack intermittently during the first 24 hours can reduce swelling. Use 10-minute intervals on the face over the treated area, followed by short breaks as needed.
Avoid tobacco
Smoking and other tobacco use delay healing and increase the chance of complications such as dry socket. Avoid these products for at least the first week after surgery when possible.
Choose gentle nourishment
Soft, lukewarm foods and plenty of fluids support recovery. Steer clear of spicy, hot, or carbonated beverages immediately after the procedure.
Care for your mouth
Brush and floss the rest of your teeth as usual, taking care to avoid the extraction site. After the first day or two, gentle rinses with warm salt water can refresh the mouth and support healing.
Attend follow-up visits
If a follow-up appointment is scheduled, keep it. Monitoring healing helps the dental team detect and address issues early and discuss timing for replacement options if needed.
Contact the practice if you notice increasing pain, persistent bleeding, a foul taste or odor, fever, or any other concerning symptoms after surgery. Timely evaluation ensures prompt care for uncommon but important complications.
When extraction becomes part of a patient’s treatment plan, a calm, experienced, and communicative team makes a meaningful difference. Our clinicians emphasize clear explanations, compassionate support, and evidence-based techniques to help ensure comfort and predictable healing. Whether a case is straightforward or needs a surgical approach, coordination and attention to detail guide the process.
We also focus on what comes next. After an extraction, restoring chewing function and esthetics—when appropriate—is part of a comprehensive treatment conversation. The dental team will review replacement options and timing so patients can make an informed choice that supports oral health for years to come.
If you have questions about tooth removal, recovery, or replacement choices, the team at Simply Smiles Dental Brooklyn is available to explain the process and walk you through the options. Contact us to learn more about extraction care and how we can support a comfortable, safe experience tailored to your needs.
The most common reasons for tooth loss include advanced periodontal disease, extensive tooth decay, and facial trauma. According to statistics, gum disease is responsible for close to 70% of tooth loss in adults. Although less frequent than the preceding three reasons, it should also be noted that specific diseases, drugs, smoking, and poor nutrition contribute to the risk of tooth loss.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention report that in the United States, an average of 12 teeth (including the wisdom teeth) are lost by the age of 50. Also, 26% of adults between 65 and 74 years of age have lost all their teeth.
Every patient and every situation is different. However, when a tooth and the surrounding tissues are numbed with a local anesthetic, you should only expect to feel a bit of pressure, but no pain as the tooth is being loosened from the surrounding tissues and extracted. For patients who are apprehensive and for some surgical extractions, our office will discuss our options in dental sedation to provide further relaxation and reduce any sense of discomfort.
While it's normal to feel some tenderness and swelling following an extraction, the degree of these sensations can vary. It mostly depends on the complexity of the extraction and the body's response to the procedure. We'll recommend or prescribe the appropriate pain medication to help ensure your comfort and give you specific instructions for maximum effectiveness and safety.
Typically, the recovery period following a simple extraction is shorter than a surgical extraction. However, a patient's overall health, habits, the size and location of the tooth, and other variables can influence recovery and healing. To speed up the recovery and avoid any complications, patients must follow the given at-home instructions diligently. We'll carefully review what to expect following your procedure and go over your post-op instructions.
Smoking interferes with blood clot formation, which is an essential first step in the healing process. Blood clot formation not only provides a protective layer to cover the underlying exposed bone and nerve endings, but it also supports the growth of new tissue. Cigarette smoke also contains chemical toxins that can disrupt the healing process and lead to problems such as continued inflammation, infection, or dry socket.
In a very small percentage of cases, a condition known as dry socket can develop in the aftermath of a dental extraction. This painful condition can arise when the blood clot in the extraction site doesn't form properly or gets dislodged. With dry socket, you may experience throbbing pain and symptoms such as bad breath and an unpleasant taste in your mouth. As skilled providers of care, our office will provide immediate treatment to alleviate your discomfort and promote healing.
The last teeth in your mouth to develop, wisdom teeth often do not have enough room to fully erupt or may be positioned in the wrong direction. These issues can affect your dental health as well as overall wellbeing. While some individuals never develop all their wisdom teeth, and a few have sufficient space for them, there are many people with partially or fully impacted third molars. Our office will monitor the development, position, and health of your wisdom teeth and will advise you if and when extractions are indicated.
After a tooth is removed, bone-grafting material is sometimes placed in the socket to promote healing and encourage new bone development. This procedure is often performed to support the eventual and successful placement of a dental implant.
At the office of Simply Smiles Dental Brooklyn, we strive to make dental care affordable and accessible. Depending on the type or complexity of the extraction and other variables, the cost of the procedure can vary. Based on our diagnostic findings, our office will inform you of the healthiest choices in care, explain the fees, discuss insurance coverage, and explain your payment options.
Many dental plans offer some level of coverage for tooth extractions. We'll advise you if your plan covers the full cost of the procedure and if there is any out-of-pocket expense. Our business office will work with you to maximize your insurance benefits as much as possible while helping you minimize any out-of-pocket expenses.
Tooth extraction becomes necessary when preserving the natural tooth would compromise long-term oral health or function. Common reasons include extensive decay that destroys structural support, fractures that extend below the gumline, advanced periodontal disease that leaves the tooth mobile, impacted third molars that cause repeated infection, and primary teeth that fail to resorb and block eruption.
Extractions are recommended only after a careful evaluation and when conservative treatments such as fillings, crowns, root canal therapy, or periodontal therapy are unlikely to provide a predictable, durable result. Your dentist will explain the reasons for recommending removal and review alternative options so you can make an informed decision about your care.
A comprehensive evaluation includes a review of your medical history, a clinical exam, and targeted imaging to assess root shape, bone levels, and proximity to important structures. Digital radiographs or 3D imaging (CBCT) help reveal hidden complications and guide whether a simple in-office extraction is appropriate or whether referral to an oral surgeon is safer.
The clinician also considers your bite, the condition of adjacent teeth, gum health, and your overall treatment goals. This assessment includes discussing the expected prognosis with and without extraction and planning any necessary follow-up restorations to preserve oral stability.
A simple extraction is performed when the tooth is fully visible in the mouth and can be loosened and removed with elevators and forceps after local anesthesia. These procedures are typically efficient and have a straightforward recovery when proper post-operative care is followed.
Surgical extractions are required for impacted teeth, roots that are curved or broken, or teeth fused to bone; the procedure may involve a small incision, removal of a bit of bone, or sectioning the tooth to allow safe removal. Surgical cases can produce slightly more swelling and may require sutures, and they are sometimes managed by or in consultation with an oral surgeon for complex anatomy or medical considerations.
Local anesthesia is used for virtually all extractions to numb the area and prevent pain during the procedure, and most patients tolerate this well for routine cases. For patients with anxiety, a low tolerance for dental procedures, or more complex surgical needs, additional options such as nitrous oxide (laughing gas), oral sedatives, or IV sedation may be offered.
The appropriate sedation choice depends on the procedure complexity, your medical history, and personal comfort levels, so these options are discussed during treatment planning. When sedation beyond local anesthesia is used, the practice will provide specific pre- and post-operative instructions and may request that you arrange transportation home after the appointment.
Before your appointment, provide a complete list of medications and medical conditions, including any blood thinners, heart conditions, diabetes, or recent illnesses, as these factors can affect surgical risk and healing. If sedation is planned, follow fasting instructions and arrange for a responsible adult to drive you home and assist for the remainder of the day as recommended.
Your dental team will review pre-operative instructions and any temporary medication adjustments with you and, if necessary, coordinate with your physician for approvals or advice. Bring a list of questions about antibiotics, pain management, and post-operative care so you feel confident and prepared before the procedure begins.
On the day of your extraction, you will be checked in and the clinician will review your medical history and treatment plan, confirm consent, and take any required imaging. Local anesthesia will be administered to numb the area, and sedation will be provided if it was prearranged; the actual procedure length varies but many routine extractions are completed within a short visit.
After the tooth is removed you will bite on gauze to control bleeding and receive clear, written post-operative instructions regarding pain control, oral hygiene, diet, and activity restrictions. If sutures are placed, the team will tell you whether they dissolve or require removal and schedule follow-up as needed to monitor healing.
Mild pain, swelling, and light bleeding are common after an extraction and typically resolve with proper care, but other issues such as infection, prolonged bleeding, or dry socket can occur in a minority of cases. In rare situations there can be nerve irritation or sinus communication with upper molar extractions, and these possibilities are discussed during consent when relevant.
If complications arise the dental team will assess the situation promptly and provide appropriate treatment, which may include local measures, prescription medications, a dressings, or referral to a specialist for further management. Timely follow-up and clear communication help ensure that uncommon problems are identified and treated quickly to protect oral health.
Protecting the blood clot that forms in the extraction socket is essential for uncomplicated healing; avoid spitting forcefully, using straws, smoking, or vigorous rinsing for the first 24–48 hours. Eat soft, lukewarm foods, maintain gentle oral hygiene avoiding the surgical site, and follow any instructions about prescribed pain relievers or antibiotics.
Applying cold packs intermittently during the first 24 hours can reduce swelling, and warm saltwater rinses after 24 hours aid cleansing without disrupting the clot. If you experience sudden severe pain a few days after the procedure, foul taste, or exposed bone in the socket, contact the dental team promptly as these can be signs of dry socket that benefit from professional care.
Replacing a missing tooth is considered when it will improve chewing function, esthetics, or long-term oral health, and the timing depends on healing, bone availability, and your overall treatment plan. Options include dental implants, fixed bridges, or removable partial dentures, and the dental team will explain which solutions are best suited to your mouth and goals.
In some situations a bone graft or socket preservation procedure is recommended at the time of extraction or shortly afterward to maintain ridge volume for future implant placement. The team at SimplySmiles coordinates restorative planning so replacement is timed appropriately and supports durable oral function and appearance.
Pediatric extractions are often focused on guiding proper eruption and development, and primary teeth that impede permanent teeth may be removed with careful planning and child-friendly techniques. For seniors, age-related changes such as reduced bone density, medication interactions, and slower healing are taken into account when determining the safest treatment approach.
Patients with medical conditions such as bleeding disorders, uncontrolled diabetes, or those taking certain medications require close coordination between the dental team and the patient’s physician to manage risk and optimize outcomes. SimplySmiles tailors treatment plans to individual needs and works with medical providers when necessary to ensure safe, effective care for all patients.
Quick Links
Contact Us
